@dank-stick2 You might have entered your true name in your profile and you 100% had to provide your birthday.
Recovery via email will be quicker, but if you can at least create a list of "likely candidates" for what email address you used, recovery might still be 'possible'. This is no race. Think about what unique information you may have inside your profile that others would not be able to see as well. The better you can make your case, the higher your chances.
Yatsufusa
'If' you have some other method you could verify your identity with, you could write a PM to Mr. Fulp* and get your OG account back that way.
Otherwise, all that's left would be to dig through your email accounts...
* https://tomfulp.newgrounds.com/
dank-stick2
Didn't know I could do that, neat. But I mean. I don't really have a way to verify my identity, and well.. There's still the issue of my email being forgotten by my smooth brain.